4511 Bay Shore Rd, Sarasota, Florida
List Price: $3,995,000
MLS Number: A4561223

  • Status: Sold
  • Sold Date: May 04, 2023
  • Square Feet: 5812
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Baths: 6
  • Garage: 2
  • City: SARASOTA
  • Zip Code: 34234
  • Year Built: 1928
Sited on 1.1 acres of direct Bay Front where Sarasota Bay is its widest provides shockingly beautiful open water views along with priceless sunsets for this classic two-story Mediterranean Revival residence. The gated estate is set back from the point where Bay Shore Road curves at Ainsley Place and is called The Etowah named for the Etowah River in north Georgia. The 5,812 sq. ft home will require a major renovation to the original structure and the large extension added to the west of the home in 1992 by local architect Frank Folsom Smith. The historic portion of the home still has an amalgam of well-proportioned rooms, its original light sconces, wood floors, and beautiful arch details. The entry features a vaulted ceiling which leads to the living room centered on a beautiful fireplace as a focal point. The sunroom is surrounded in with windows of original circus glass. The dining room is on scale for entertaining. The adjacent kitchen is privy to an old fashioned back staircase leading to the second level. The 2nd level features the original owner's bedroom claiming front and center position onto the view with 3 other bedrooms on this level. In the added wing, an oversized Great Room, an auxiliary kitchen and large owner's quarters with a walk-in closet and spacious bath provide open water views. An original garage joins the home with separate 2nd level guest quarters.. The covered boathouse is also historically designated. The home has been unoccupied for a considerable period of time. A serious renovation is required. The list price is considered to represent land value.

Misc Info

Subdivision: Indian Beach Map Of

Annual Taxes: $49,836

Water Front: Bay/Harbor

Water View: Bay/Harbor - Full

Water Access: Bay/Harbor

Water Extras: Boathouse, Seawall - Concrete

Lot Size: 1 to less than 2

  • Listing Image #2
  • Listing Image #3
  • Listing Image #4
  • Listing Image #5
  • Listing Image #6
  • Listing Image #7
  • Listing Image #8
  • Listing Image #9
  • Listing Image #10
  • Listing Image #11
  • Listing Image #12
  • Listing Image #13
  • Listing Image #14
  • Listing Image #15
  • Listing Image #16
  • Listing Image #17
  • Listing Image #18
  • Listing Image #19
  • Listing Image #20

Request the MLS data sheet for this property


    Sold Information

    CDD: $3,250,000

    Sold Price per Sqft: $ 559.19 / sqft

    Home Features

    Appliances: None

    Flooring: Tile, Wood

    Air Conditioning: Central Air

    Exterior: French Doors, Sidewalk

    Garage Features: Driveway

    Room Dimensions

    Schools

    • Elementary: Emma E. Booker Elementary
    • High: Booker High
    • Map
    • Walk Score
    • Street View